Talk to us
Enrollment is open — Join today, start today. No cohorts, no waiting. See Enrollment Options →
Private Practice

Medicare Opt-Out for PMHNPs: A Cash-Pay Playbook

Medicare opt-out for PMHNPs: the affidavit, the 10-day rule, private contracts, two-year renewals, and the mistakes that put a cash-pay practice at risk.

Private practice desk with a signed contract, pen, key and sealed envelope representing a PMHNP Medicare opt-out filing


Audio Overview

Listen to an in-depth podcast of this post

Medicare opt-out for PMHNPs overview: two hosts break down the full article — no reading required.

Read the transcript

You know, usually when you pour your heart into starting a business, you get to decide exactly how you want to operate. Right. You set your own terms. Exactly. I mean, think about it like this.

If you open a completely vegan bakery, you don't expect a sudden letter from the federal government forcing you to start selling turkey sandwiches. No, of course not. Right. Just because one of your loyal, longtime customers decided they suddenly want to eat meat, you just politely tell them to, you know, go to a deli. Yeah.

And the beauty of independent business is supposed to be that level of control. You set a specific model, and as long as you operate within standard commercial laws, you basically have the autonomy to decide what services you provide and to whom. It gives you boundaries. Exactly. It gives a practice owner a sense of boundaries and predictability.

But then you step into the world of independent health care practice, and specifically for psychiatric nurse practitioners, or PMHNPs. And that basic rule of free market business just gets flipped completely upside down. It really does. Like, you can be running a strict cash pay only practice. You're completely off the insurance grid.

Yep. Keeping your overhead low. Minding your own business. And then one of your favorite long time patients has a birthday. And that single birthday changes the entire legal landscape of that relationship.

It's crazy. It is. A regulatory trap door essentially opens underneath your practice. And you are instantly entangled with the federal government's Medicare rules. Whether you realize it or not.

Exactly. For the uninformed practice owner, it is the absolute definition of a compliance nightmare. Okay, let's unpack this because our mission for this deep dive is to explore a crucial, genuinely eye-opening playbook tailored for new and early career psychiatric nurse practitioners. It's such an important topic. It really is.

We're drawing primarily from a brilliant article titled, Medicare Opt Out for PMHNPs, a cash pay playbook. And that was written by Lindsay Hill and published by the Psych NP Fellowship. And we should mention we're also using the actual federal regulations and official CMS guidelines as our factual backdrop today. Right. No rumors today.

Yeah. Because when you're dealing with federal health care law, hearsay from a Facebook group just won't hold up in an audit. Oh, definitely not. So we need to look closely at the actual statutory mechanics that are outlined in Lindsay's playbook. OK.

So let's set up the core conflict from the article. I want you to imagine you're a PMH NP running a successful cash pay practice. You charge, let's say, $300 for a 30-minute follow-up appointment. Sounds pretty standard. Right.

So you have a patient you've been seeing for years. They turn 65. And like most people do, they enroll in Medicare Part B. Yep. As the practitioner, your internal logic says, well, I don't take Medicare.

I'm strictly cash pay. I've never even signed up for the program. So you just keep collecting your $300 cash. Right. You just assume Medicare has absolutely nothing to do with your private clinic.

And that assumption is just incredibly common. But it is a massive legal hazard. Like a huge trap. Yeah. The foundational rule you have to grasp is this.

A 66-year-old is a Medicare beneficiary, regardless of your enrollment status. Okay. The psychiatric services you're providing are federally defined as Medicare covered services. So, unless you have formally, legally severed ties with the program, Medicare's rules still govern that interaction. You can't just close your eyes and pretend the system doesn't exist.

No, you really can't. So, to fix a compliance issue like this, we really need to understand the flaw in that foundational logic. I think a lot of practitioners assume there's a gray area. Like, why isn't, I just don't take Medicare, a sufficient legal stance for an independent nurse practitioner? It really comes down to a structural difference in how federal statutes categorize different types of medical providers.

OK. So physicians, for example, they actually have a middle ground option built into the law. Really? Yeah. A doctor can choose to be what's called non-participating.

OK. What does that mean? It means they don't accept the standard Medicare rate as full payment, and they're allowed to charge the patient a bit more, up to a strict legal limit, while the patient can still get a portion of that reimbursed by Medicare. I see. but psychiatric nurse practitioners simply do not have this middle path available to them.

I'm assuming that has to do with how the government historically views nursing versus physician billing. Yeah, it's basically a quirk of legislative history. Under the federal regulations governing advanced practice nurses, NP services are mandated to be paid only on an assignment related basis. Meaning what exactly? That legal phrase means if you're dealing with a Medicare beneficiary, you must accept the Medicare assignment amount as payment in full.

Which is usually less. Right. For NPs, that's generally 85 % of the standard physician fee schedule. Ouch. And you cannot balance bill.

You cannot charge the beneficiary a single penny more than what Medicare allows. Wow. So because that middle ground is legally erased for NPs, you're forced into two extreme choices. Exactly. You either enroll, take the 85 % fee schedule and accept the lower reimbursement, or you have to formally opt out of the system entirely.

It is a strict binary. Enroll or opt out. That I'll just charge my normal cash rate and fly under the radar option. It simply does not exist in the eyes of the federal government. It's like being drafted into a club by default just because your patient had a birthday.

Right. And you aren't allowed to just stand quietly in the doorway. You're either fully in the club, abide in by their fee schedules, or you have to file complex paperwork to officially renounce your membership. That's a great way to put it. But wait, let me throw a hypothetical at you.

OK, go for it. What if my practice is exclusively college students? Like, I specialize in young adult ADHD. I simply never see anyone over 65. Ah.

Well, in that highly specific scenario, you actually are safe. Really? Yeah. OK. Yeah.

If you strictly never treat Medicare beneficiaries, meaning you rigorously screen out anyone 65 and older, and you also screen out younger individuals who might be on disability-based Medicare, then you don't need to take any action. So no enrollment, no opt-out. Correct. However, the very moment one of those younger patients qualifies for disability Medicare or an existing patient ages in, the services you provide automatically flip to being Medicare covered. So you're right back in the trap.

Exactly. You know, Lindsay Hill sums this up with a quote from her article that I think every independent practice owner needs printed and framed above their desk. Oh, I love this quote. Yeah. She writes, the question isn't whether you take Medicare, it's whether you've told Medicare in writing that you don't.

That frames the bureaucratic reality perfectly. I mean, the default setting of the American health care system for seniors is that Medicare is involved. Right. You have to actively, affirmatively declare your independence from it. OK.

So if ignoring Medicare is illegal for these specific patients, how do we actually tell the government we want out? Like, what is the mechanism? So the mechanism requires two distinct operational steps. The first is a federally recognized document called the Opt Out Affidavit. An affidavit?

Sounds serious. It is. It's a formal written declaration. where you swear to the government that you will only treat Medicare beneficiaries under private contracts, that no one will submit a claim for your services, and that you will not receive Medicare payment directly or indirectly. Not even through an Advantage plan.

Nope, not even through a Medicare Advantage plan. I imagine I can't just mail this affidavit to the White House or a generic federal PO box, right? Definitely not. I have to actively serve this notice to whoever actually handles the money. Yes.

You have to file it with your regional Medicare administrative contractor, which is often called a MAC. MAC. Got it. These are the private insurance companies that hold geographic contracts to process Medicare claims on behalf of the government. And here's the kicker.

You must file the affidavit with every MAC that would theoretically process your claims if you hadn't opted out. Oh, wow. Let's apply this to a modern practice reality, then, because telehealth has just completely changed the game. Oh, absolutely. Let's say I'm a PMHNP living in Arizona, but I'm also licensed in Texas, and I see cash pay patients virtually in both states.

Well, this is where the administrative overhead starts to really creep in. Arizona and Texas fall under two completely different MAC jurisdictions. Uh-oh. So the rules dictate that you must submit two separate original opt-out affidavits. One goes to the MAC covering your Arizona practice, and one to the MAC for Texas.

So if I add a telehealth license in New York next year… You need a third affidavit. You have to opt out everywhere your license allows you to practice. That is wild. And the timelines for filing this paperwork are incredibly unforgiving too, right?

Very unforgiving. Let's break down the clock. Let's start with someone who is currently a participating Medicare provider but wants to transition to a pure cash pay model. Okay, so for an enrolled provider, you're actually only allowed to opt out at the beginning of a calendar quarter. So January 1st, April 1st, July 1st, and October 1st.

Okay, simple enough. But your affidavit must be physically received by the MAC at least 30 days before that quarter begins. Ah. So if you plan to break free on January 1st, your paperwork must be in their hands by early December. Okay, but what about the practitioner from our earlier example?

The one who has never enrolled in Medicare has always been cash pay and suddenly realizes a patient just turned 65. What's fascinating here is the timeline for the never enrolled practitioner is quite frankly terrifying. Really? Yeah. The federal regulations state that you can opt out at any time.

Your two-year opt-out period begins the date you've signed the affidavit, but only if you file it with the MAC. within 10 days after you sign your first private contract with a Medicare patient. Wait, 10 days? Yes. That is an absolute blink of an eye in administrative time.

You see a newly 65-year-old patient on a Tuesday and you have until the following Friday to get this official federal document delivered to the MAC? That's the rule. I have to assume that 10-day window is intentionally tight. The government probably doesn't want practitioners waiting until they get caught in an audit and then trying to retroactively backdate and opt out to save themselves. That is exactly the rationale.

The government demands upfront clarity. They just hate ambiguity regarding financial liability. Sure. So if you miss that 10-day window, your opt-out does not retroactively apply. It only starts on the day the paperwork is finally processed.

Oh no. Which means any services you provided to that Medicare beneficiary before the paperwork was filed are suddenly subject to standard Medicare rules. So you are suddenly liable for taking a $300 cash payment when you should have been strictly bound by the 85 % fee schedule. Exactly. Which perfectly explains why Lindsay's playbook advises a much safer operational sequence.

She essentially says don't play games with the 10-day clock. Right. Don't even risk it. Her advice is to sign the affidavit, file it with the MAC, obtain proof of delivery, and secure your opted-out status before you ever sign a patient contract or render a service. Basically, preempt the clock entirely.

It is the only foolproof way to ensure you aren't accidentally operating out of compliance while you're just waiting on the mail. Okay, so telling the MAC you are opting out is step one. Step two involves the patient, because by opting out, you are effectively removing their federal safety net for the services you provide. Right. You are asking a senior citizen to formally waive their right to use their Medicare benefits for your clinical care.

Which requires more paperwork. Yes, it requires a highly specific legally binding document called the private contract. I really look at this private contract as a federal prenuptial agreement between three parties, the practitioner, the patient, and Medicare. That's a very accurate comparison. Right, it's a literal separation of assets.

The patient is legally agreeing that their Medicare benefits won't touch your practice, and you are agreeing you won't try to touch their federal funds. Exactly. This isn't just a standard intake form where they just click I agree on an iPad. No, not at all. The requirements for this contract are incredibly rigid.

For instance, the regulations specifically dictate that the contract must be in writing and the print must be sufficiently large to ensure the beneficiary can actually read it. Wow. It's essentially codified into law that you can't use fine print to trick a senior citizen into waiving their health care rights. Right. It's a strict consumer protection measure.

That makes sense. And the required language is extensive. The contract must explicitly state that the patient or their legal representative accepts full financial responsibility for payment. OK. It must acknowledge that Medicare's strict charge limits no longer apply, meaning the practitioner is free to charge whatever their market rate is.

Got it. Crucially, It must state that neither the patient nor the practitioner will attempt to submit a claim to Medicare for these services. So the patient can't go home, look at their $300 receipt and decide on a whim to mail it into Medicare just to see if they can get a partial reimbursement. They are legally binding themselves not to do that. Correct.

The contract also has to state the exact effective and expiration dates of your specific two-year opt-out period. Right. It must confirm the patient knows they have the right to seek care from a different enrolled practitioner. And it must warn the patient that Medigap or other supplemental insurance plans will likely refuse to pay for these services as well. So from a practical workflow perspective, operationalizing these rules is where practice owners usually stumble.

Like, when does this multi-page federal prenup actually get signed? The absolute rule is that the patient must receive and sign this private contract before any service is rendered. Before? Yes. You cannot conduct a 45-minute psychiatric evaluation, realize at the very end that they are 65, and ask them to sign the waiver on their way out the door.

Too late at that point. Way too late. The financial boundary must be established before the clinical work begins. And as the business owner, you are required to retain the original double-signed copies of these contracts for the full duration of your two-year opt-out period, right? Yes.

And if CMS initiates an audit, you have to produce them immediately. Which is exactly where Lindsay makes a incredibly smart connection regarding daily operations. She advises bundling this Medicare private contract with the good faith estimate that is now required by the No Surprises Act. You just put them both into the exact same financial intake packet so neither of these massive compliance documents accidentally gets skipped by your front desk. It's a brilliant administrative strategy honestly.

You consolidate your regulatory compliance into a single cohesive onboarding step. So we've covered the paperwork. The affidavit is filed. the large print contract assigned, what does day-to-day practice actually look like now? Does opting out completely isolate the practitioner from the rest of the healthcare ecosystem?

Well, not entirely. Let me pose a practical clinical dilemma. Let's say a Medicare patient shows up to your clinic in an absolute crisis, a severe acute urgent care scenario, but they haven't signed this massive prenuptial contract yet. Right. You can't exactly make someone in acute psychiatric distress sit down and initial large print legal clauses, right?

No, and the federal government recognizes the ethical nightmare that would create. This brings us to the urgent care exception. OK, good. If a Medicare patient requires emergency or urgent care, the PMHNP is legally permitted to treat them without a private contract in place. But if they haven't signed the contract agreeing to pay my cash rate, how do I get compensated for my time?

In this highly specific crisis scenario, you actually submit a claim to Medicare for that urgent visit. Oh, wow. OK. However, because you are an opted-out practitioner, you are only permitted to collect the standard deductible and co-insurance from the patient. I see.

What's vital for practitioners to understand is that doing this correctly, treating the crisis, submitting the claim, and limiting your collection does not break or invalidate your opt-out status for your broader practice. Okay, that's a huge relief. Yeah, it functions as a built-in safety valve to ensure acute clinical needs are met. That makes total sense, especially for anyone worried about patient abandonment. But what about more routine clinical functions like ordering laps?

If I have a cash-pay patient on a medication like lithium, which requires regular blood-level monitoring, am I entirely cut off from the medical infrastructure? Do they have to pay cash for their blood work too? No, no. The opt-out status is specifically tied to the professional services you provide. Oh, just my time?

Right. An opted-out PMHNP retains their full medical license and authority to order labs, imaging, and certify other services. The clinical visit with you is strictly cash pay, governed by the private contract. But when the patient takes your lab order to a facility to get their blood drawn… The lab can still bill Medicare.

Exactly. That lab facility can still bill Medicare for the test itself. Your opt-out status prevents you from billing for your diagnostic time. But it does not invalidate the medical necessity of the test you order. That's a really crucial distinction, separating the provider's time from the facility's service.

Definitely. What about Medicare Advantage plans? A lot of patients will argue, oh, I don't have government Medicare. I have a private Advantage plan through a major commercial insurer. So this cash pay contract doesn't apply to me.

Yeah, the patient is mistaken there, and the practitioner cannot fall for that logic. Federal regulations stipulate that Medicare Advantage plans are treated exactly like original Medicare in this specific context. So no loopholes. No loopholes. An Advantage plan is legally prohibited from paying an opted-out practitioner for basic covered services.

If your patient has an Advantage plan, they are a Medicare beneficiary. Period. Period. They must sign the private contract. pay out of pocket, and neither of you can submit a claim to the Advantage plan.

Wow. Let's discuss the life cycle of the status, because you've mentioned the two-year period several times now. Do you just file this affidavit once and you're opted out for the rest of your career? Not quite. The opt-out status operates on a strict two-year cycle, and it is designed to auto-renew indefinitely.

OK. If a practitioner decides they want to get back into the Medicare system, say they're moving to a group practice that takes insurance, they can't just tear up the private contracts and start billing. You are only permitted to terminate and opt out early within the very first 90 days of your initial filing. Like a probationary cancellation period. Exactly.

If you pass that 90-day mark, you're locked out for the remainder of the two years. To stop the auto renewal for the next cycle, you must submit a formal cancellation request to your MAC with at least 30 days notice before your current to your period expires. Yeah, and that is the kind of expiration date you need to put on your digital calendar the very day you mail the affidavit with multiple reminders leading up to it. Absolutely. So we've laid out the black and white rules.

But human nature being what it is, I can imagine the mental gymnastics people do to avoid this paperwork. People always try to find loopholes. Always. Right. And Lindsay outlined several common myths in her article.

And I'd love to explore the logic behind why they fail. Here's where it gets really interesting. For instance, What if a practitioner thinks, I want to do good in my community. I'll just accept Medicare for my low-income patients, but I'll implement this opt-out contract for my wealthy cash-pay patients. Yeah.

That is known as the partial opt-out myth, and it is a massive compliance failure. No good deed goes unpunished, right? Right. The law simply does not allow you to opt out on a patient by patient basis. It is an all or nothing legal status tied to your specific national provider identifier or NPI.

So it's tied to you, not the patient. Exactly. If you opt out, every single Medicare patient you see outside of that narrow urgent care exception must sign a private contract and pay out of pocket. You cannot straddle the fence based on a patient's income. OK, here's another workaround I could see a well-meaning practitioner trying.

The patient signs the prenup. pays the $300 cash, but then asks the PMHNP for a super bill so they can try to get reimbursed by Medicare on their own. The practitioner thinks, sure, I do this for my out-of-network commercial patients all the time. Here's your receipt with the diagnostic codes. Oh, providing a super bill to a Medicare patient when you have opted out completely defeats the legal purpose of the private contract.

Because they agreed not to submit anything. Right. Remember, the core of that contract is the patient explicitly agreeing not to ask Medicare for reimbursement. If they take that super bill and submit a claim, they are violating the contract, which in turn threatens your regulatory status as the provider. That's a disaster.

It is. Medicare will reject the claim. And as the contract is required to warn them, their secondary Medigap plans likely won't pay it either. Do not hand out super bills to Medicare patients if you are opted out. Okay, let's quickly reiterate the lab orders myth just because it scares so many people away from cash pay models.

The myth is, if I opt out, I can't order labs or imaging for seniors. Completely false. You retain your full prescriptive and diagnostic authority. Your clinical time is cash. Their downstream testing at third-party facilities can still be covered by their insurance.

Perfect. And the final myth, opting out is a lifetime sentence. If I leave the system, I can never go back. Also false. As we discussed with the auto renewal mechanics, it is a two-year cycle.

As long as you are organized enough to catch that 30-day cancellation window before it auto renews, you are never permanently banned from returning to Medicare if your business model or career path changes. Which actually brings us to a really counter-intuitive but brilliant piece of advice from Lindsay's playbook. Oh, about the reflex opt-out. Yes. Beware of the reflex opt out.

A lot of early career practitioners hear about all these terrifying rules, the 10 day windows, the large print contracts, and they panic. They think, wow, I need to opt out immediately just to protect myself from an audit. And reacting out of pure fear can be a strategic business mistake. Totally. Lindsay advises practitioners to actually sit down and do the math.

Sometimes when you analyze your specific patient panel, you realize that staying enrolled in Medicare accepting the 85 % fee schedule and simply billing the government is actually more profitable and creates far less friction than forcing your established 65 plus patients to sign complex prenuptial style contracts and pay high out-of-pocket fees. The administrative burden of opting out just isn't always worth the cash pay rate. Exactly. It's about knowing your numbers before you jump. So let's bring all this complex federal machinery down to a concrete action plan for you the listener.

If you are listening to this deep dive and you own a practice, here is your 15-minute fix recommended by the article. This is such good advice. Right. Open your electronic health record system today. Run a demographic filter.

List every single patient who is 65 or older, anyone you know who is on disability-based Medicare, and anyone who is celebrating their 65th birthday this calendar year. If there is even one name on that list and you haven't actively addressed your Medicare status, you need to pause your operations and act. Locate your regional MAC, request the opt-out affidavit form, and get your compliance strategy finalized before you render another service. It's just a small, focused administrative lift right now that acts as an insurance policy against a massive, financially devastating compliance audit later. And navigating these exact kinds of high-stakes business and clinical crossroads is exactly why Lindsay Hill created the 12-month mentorship program over at the Psych NP Fellowship.

When you are building an independent practice, having a guide who has already mapped the regulatory minefield is absolutely invaluable. It really is. And, you know, if we pull back and connect this hyper-specific regulation to the macro trends in healthcare, this raises a vital question for the entire psychiatric field. We are currently staring down the barrel of the silver tsunami. Oh, yeah.

The massive aging baby boomer population is crashing into the healthcare system. The mental health sector is going to see unprecedented record-breaking numbers of Medicare-eligible patients in the coming years. The demographic shift is undeniable. Almost every practice is going to feel it. Which leaves us with this final implication to ponder.

If independent practitioners don't master these regulatory frameworks right now, will the pure cash pay model even be sustainable in a decade? That's a scary thought. Or will this massive demographic wave of Medicare patients effectively force everyone back into the insurance matrix just to maintain a viable patient panel and keep their doors open? That is a fascinating and perhaps slightly daunting question to leave off on. As the market shifts, knowing the rules is basically the only way to maintain your independence.

Thank you so much for joining us to explore this material. Keep looking closely at those rules and we'll catch you on the next Deep Dive.

Machine-generated transcript of the AI-voiced audio overview. Also on the Deep Dive podcast.

TL;DR

  • A PMHNP who never enrolled in Medicare can’t just collect cash from Medicare patients. Without a formal opt-out, the services are still Medicare-covered and Medicare’s rules still apply.
  • Nurse practitioners must accept assignment on Medicare claims, so the physician-style “non-participating” middle path isn’t open to them. The real choice is enroll or opt out.
  • Opting out takes two documents: a signed affidavit filed with every Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) you’d bill, and a private contract signed by each Medicare patient before care.
  • If you were never enrolled, file the affidavit within 10 days of signing your first private contract. Previously participating? File at least 30 days before the calendar quarter you want.
  • Opt-out lasts two years and renews automatically. You can cancel at least 30 days before a period ends, and you can only end an initial opt-out early within its first 90 days.
  • Opted-out PMHNPs can still order labs and certify services, but Medicare Advantage plans can’t pay them for basic covered care.

Ten days. That’s how long a PMHNP who has never enrolled in Medicare gets to file an opt-out affidavit after signing a first private contract with a Medicare patient. Most new practice owners have never heard of the deadline, because most of them think they don’t need to do anything at all.

The usual logic sounds airtight. “I’m cash-pay. I never signed up for Medicare. So Medicare has nothing to do with me.” It’s wrong. A 66-year-old patient is a Medicare beneficiary whether or not you ever enrolled, and the services you provide are still Medicare-covered services unless you’ve formally opted out.

That matters more every year. Cash-pay and hybrid models are spreading (we compared them in Cash Pay vs. Insurance-Based PMHNP Practice), and patients who turn 65 don’t stop needing psychiatric care. A practice that wants to keep those patients on a cash basis needs two documents, a few dates on the calendar, and a clear understanding of what the rules allow.

This playbook walks through all of it: who can opt out, how the affidavit works, what the private contract must say, and what still applies once you’re out.

Five stepping stones showing the PMHNP Medicare opt-out process: decide, sign private contracts, file the affidavit, stay compliant, track the two-year renewal

Why “I Don’t Take Medicare” Isn’t Enough

Physicians have three Medicare options: participate, stay non-participating, or opt out. Nurse practitioners effectively have two. Under 42 CFR 410.75, NP services are paid only on an assignment-related basis, and the NP may not charge the beneficiary more than Medicare allows.

In plain terms, an NP can’t be “enrolled but charging my own rate.” If you’re in Medicare, you accept the Medicare amount (NPs are generally paid at 85% of the physician fee schedule) and bill Medicare for covered services. If you want to set your own fee, you opt out.

There is a third situation: you simply never see Medicare beneficiaries. CMS says practitioners who don’t treat Medicare patients don’t need to enroll or opt out. That works for a practice that screens out patients 65 and older and those on disability-based Medicare. It stops working the day one of your existing patients ages into Medicare.

Here’s the scenario that catches people. A PMHNP runs a cash-pay practice charging $300 for a 30-minute follow-up. A long-time patient turns 65 and enrolls in Part B. Without an opt-out on file, that patient’s visits are still covered services, so the PMHNP can’t simply keep collecting $300. The practice either enrolls and bills Medicare at the fee schedule rate, or files an opt-out and signs a private contract with the patient before the next visit.

“The question isn’t whether you take Medicare. It’s whether you’ve told Medicare, in writing, that you don’t. New practice owners skip that step because no one tells them it exists, and then a patient’s 65th birthday turns into a compliance problem.”

Lindsay Hill, DNP, PMHNP-BC

Garden path splitting toward a government building and a small clinic, illustrating the PMHNP choice between Medicare enrollment and opting out

The Opt-Out Affidavit and the 10-Day Clock

The opt-out affidavit is a short signed statement. Your MAC can send you its standard form, and CMS lists the required statements on its Manage Your Enrollment page. It must include your name, address, phone number, and NPI, and it must state that:

  • Outside emergency or urgent care, you’ll treat Medicare beneficiaries only under private contracts.
  • No one will submit a Medicare claim for your services during the opt-out period.
  • You won’t receive Medicare payment directly or indirectly, including through a Medicare Advantage plan.
  • You’ll be bound by the affidavit and by every private contract you sign.

File it with every MAC that would otherwise process your claims. A telehealth PMHNP licensed in Arizona and Texas, for example, falls under two different MAC jurisdictions and needs two affidavits.

When the opt-out starts

Timing depends on your history with Medicare, under 42 CFR 405.410:

  • Never enrolled, or enrolled as non-participating: You can opt out at any time. The two-year period starts on the date you sign the affidavit, as long as you file it within 10 days after signing your first private contract with a Medicare patient. Miss that window and the period starts only when the last required affidavit is filed. Services before then fall under standard Medicare rules.
  • Currently participating: You can opt out at the start of any calendar quarter, but the affidavit must reach your MAC at least 30 days before that quarter begins. To opt out on January 1, it has to be filed by December 2.

The safest sequence for a new practice is simple. Sign the affidavit, file it, and keep proof of delivery before you sign your first private contract. Then you’re never racing the 10-day clock.

What the Private Contract Must Say

Every Medicare patient you see for cash needs a signed private contract. The required elements are set out in 42 CFR 405.415, and a contract that’s missing any of them doesn’t protect you. It must:

  1. Be in writing, in print large enough for the patient to read.
  2. State whether you are excluded from Medicare.
  3. State that the patient (or legal representative) accepts full responsibility for payment.
  4. Acknowledge that Medicare’s charge limits don’t apply to your fees.
  5. Include the patient’s agreement not to submit a claim to Medicare or ask you to.
  6. Acknowledge that Medicare won’t pay for services it would otherwise cover.
  7. Confirm the patient can get Medicare-covered care from clinicians who haven’t opted out and isn’t required to sign.
  8. List the effective and expiration dates of your current two-year opt-out period.
  9. Note that Medigap and other supplemental plans may not pay for these services.
  10. Be signed by the patient (or representative) and by you.

Three operational rules go with it. The patient gets the contract before any service under it. You keep the originals with both signatures for the full two-year period and produce them if CMS asks. And you sign a new contract with each patient for every new two-year period.

One more thing: the private contract doesn’t replace your other self-pay paperwork. Uninsured and self-pay patients may still be owed a good faith estimate under the No Surprises Act, which we covered in PMHNP Good Faith Estimates: The $400 Dispute Trap. Build both into the same intake packet so neither gets skipped.

Renewals, Urgent Care, and Ordering Labs

Opting out isn’t a one-time event you can forget about. Four rules shape the rest of it.

Two-year automatic renewals

Each opt-out period lasts two years and renews on its own. To return to Medicare, mail your MAC a cancellation request at least 30 days before the current period ends. You can end an initial opt-out early only within its first 90 days. After the first automatic renewal, that option is gone, so put the expiration date on your calendar the day you file.

The urgent-care exception

If a Medicare patient without a private contract needs emergency or urgent care, you can treat them, but you can’t ask them to sign a contract in that moment. Under 42 CFR 405.440, you submit a claim to Medicare, and as a practitioner you may collect only the deductible and coinsurance. Handled that way, it doesn’t break your opt-out.

Ordering and certifying

CMS lets opted-out practitioners order and certify Medicare items and services for their patients. A Medicare patient on lithium can still have the lab bill Medicare for the levels you order. Your own visit is cash, but the lab work you order doesn’t have to be.

Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage plans can’t pay opted-out practitioners for basic covered services. So a patient with an Advantage plan is in the same position as one with original Medicare: private contract, out-of-pocket payment, no claim.

What Most People Get Wrong

The most common mistake is treating opt-out as a billing preference. It’s a legal status with paperwork, deadlines, and an all-or-nothing scope. These are the misunderstandings that come up most often:

  • “I’ll opt out just for my cash patients.” You can’t. CMS is explicit: you can’t opt out for some patients or services and not others. Once you’re out, every Medicare patient you see (outside urgent care) needs a private contract.
  • “My Medicare patients can submit a superbill.” They can’t. The contract says no claim goes to Medicare, and Medigap may not pay either. That’s very different from the out-of-network reimbursement your commercially insured patients may get.
  • “Opting out means I can’t order labs or imaging.” You can still order and certify, so your patients’ monitoring labs can still be covered.
  • “Opt-out is permanent.” It renews every two years, but you can cancel with 30 days’ notice before a period ends. You aren’t locked in for life.
  • “Medicare changes don’t affect a cash practice.” They shape your decision. If you’re weighing whether to come back in, fee schedule changes like the ones in Medicare 2027 Proposed Rule: 3 Shifts PMHNPs Face are part of the math.

The opposite mistake happens too: opting out by reflex. Some PMHNPs would do better enrolling, billing at the fee schedule, and keeping their 65-plus patients without a contract barrier. Before you decide, run the numbers using Medicare and Medicaid Billing for PMHNPs. Working through decisions like this with experienced mentors is a big part of what the Psych NP Fellowship offers.

Magnifying glass over documents beside a broken chain and shield, illustrating common Medicare opt-out myths among PMHNPs

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a nurse practitioner opt out of Medicare?

Yes. CMS lists nurse practitioners among the practitioner types that can opt out, along with physicians, physician assistants, clinical nurse specialists, clinical psychologists, and several other groups. You file a signed opt-out affidavit with each MAC you would otherwise bill and sign a private contract with every Medicare patient.

Do I need to opt out if I never enrolled in Medicare?

Only if you plan to see Medicare beneficiaries. CMS says practitioners who don’t see Medicare patients don’t need to enroll or opt out. If you’ll treat even one Medicare patient for cash, opting out is how you do it legally.

How long does a Medicare opt-out last?

Each opt-out period lasts two years and renews automatically. To leave, send your MAC a cancellation request at least 30 days before the current period ends. Early termination is only possible within the first 90 days of an initial affidavit.

Can an opted-out PMHNP still order labs for Medicare patients?

Yes. CMS allows opted-out practitioners to order and certify Medicare items and services for their Medicare patients. A lithium level or metabolic panel you order can still be covered when the lab bills Medicare.

Can a Medicare patient submit a superbill for my cash visit?

No. In the private contract the patient agrees not to submit a claim to Medicare, and Medicare won’t pay for services furnished under it. Medigap and other supplemental plans may not pay either, which the contract must say.

What happens if a Medicare patient needs urgent care and has no private contract?

You can still treat them, but you can’t ask them to sign a contract in that moment. You submit a claim to Medicare and, as a nurse practitioner, collect only the deductible and coinsurance. Doing this correctly doesn’t break your opt-out.

Calendar with a renewal arrow, hourglass and first-aid kit, illustrating the two-year opt-out renewal and urgent-care exception

The Bottom Line

A cash-pay practice that sees Medicare patients without an opt-out isn’t out of Medicare. It’s out of compliance. The fix isn’t complicated: a signed affidavit filed with every MAC that covers you, a compliant private contract signed before each Medicare patient’s care, and a calendar reminder for the two-year renewal.

Your next step takes about 15 minutes. List every current patient who is 65 or older or on disability-based Medicare, and every patient who will turn 65 in the next year. If that list isn’t empty, call your MAC this week, request its opt-out affidavit form, and file it before you sign a single private contract.

Build your practice with people who have done it

Questions like this are easier with people in your corner. The Psych NP Fellowship is a 12-month clinical mentorship for PMHNPs: weekly live coaching on real cases, and a place to ask anything without judgment.

Explore the Psych NP Fellowship

This content is for educational purposes and does not replace individualized clinical judgment or supervision.

Lindsay Hill, DNP, PMHNP-BC is the founder of the Psych NP Fellowship, a 12-month clinical mentorship program for new and early-career psychiatric nurse practitioners. She is a published contributor to Psychiatric Times, past President of the Arizona APNA Chapter, and co-founder of the Psych NP Network.

About Psych NP Fellowship Team

The Psych NP Fellowship Team provides evidence-based clinical content, prescribing insights, and career guidance for new and early-career psychiatric nurse practitioners. Led by Lindsay Hill, DNP, PMHNP-BC, the team is dedicated to bridging the gap between PMHNP education and confident clinical practice.

Related Posts

Ready to Practice with Calm Confidence?

Book a free 20-minute call with our team, or join the Psych NP Fellowship today: $297/mo for 12 months, or $2,997 paid in full.

Talk to Our Team

or see the Fellowship →